Seductive, sacrificial, martyr are all characteristics that define Becky Sharp in Mira Nair’s Vanity Fair. Characters in this adaptation are heroes; they have spines and are quite unlike the one dimensional characters in the written form of Vanity Fair. Besides the behavior which transforms Becky and Amelia to victims of wartime and gambling, there are signifiers in dress, decorum, and music. Becky is assigned the color red, she is most striking, or seductive, when dancing or singing which allows Becky more freedom while constraining her at the same time. There is juxtaposition in the film between the idea of freedom and entrapment, this idea that no matter what the class distinction there is still the idea of an overarching patriarchy. Becky is free because she has choice but this choice she gains within the salary of the wealthy benefactors she meets along the way. In this way, Becky Sharp is objectified because she becomes a purely sexual object in the realm of wealthy society. The extravagances in her dress, which contrast the other women who are almost always dressed in white, offset her deviant nature which is quite outside society. In Mira Nair's film, Becky becomes are purely sexual object, which is helped with the colorful motifs that relate more to an Indian culture than to the English culture that focuses on propriety and manners.
What is interesting in the film is the way Becky is used to fight sexual objectification in her clever ways of using the gentleman and also the way she is portrayed in the end as a matryr. The end explains it all with the choice to end the film right at India, which appears to be Becky's goal throught the film. Atleast, that is how it seems with the bright colors and wondrous peacocks that make their way through the film. In the film it seems as though Becky's ending is deserved, that she has earned her place by Joseph Sedley's side. Her migration from England to India is just another way of saying that she was too much of an outsider to exist within that society so the solution was to displace her within in a culture where she could fit in. Her evil nature is completely misunderstood as somebody who does not fit in so forget all those hideous portraits of her in darkness slowly killing her husband. In the ending it is also interesting to see how irrelevant Amelia's life is. It was kind of the screenwriter to give her a bit more character but in doing so they had to cut her significantly from the plot. Amelia is no longer the poor innocent angel, she is a slightly boring young woman who follows along the plot.
Becky, instead, drives the plot and runs it along with her ambitious, not to say malevolent, desire to get ahead in life. She is a tease, a wonder and talent to look at which is why in this film Becky is the victim. She is too much objectified to be protagonist because she is the manipulater and the manipulated in the great scheme of playing men off to gain a fortune.
Now that the themes have been established its important to see how filmic techniques were used to create such a visual. Color has already been discussed as a means to show Becky's deviance from the social norm, and also the means in portraying India as the other culture that dimly exists within England. Thus, color is used to portray a progression, to show that Becky does not fit the norm that exists with all the women wearing the extremely familiar white gown that offsets her blood red. Besides color, even the camera is used in a way to objectify Becky and make her into a sexual object. One shot goes to show her looking at herself through the mirror while her husband stands behind her. Many of the shots focus first on the breasts, on the hands and the whole portrait of her body instead of her face. Men are seen always in the full body shot in a way that reflects their economic superiority. Becky is always dressed in extravagance and the men always dressed impeccably as if there's no other way to stand next to Becky. Even the soundtrack and dance have Indian undertones and Becky's dance spoke more of the nature of women and the dance in Pride and Prejudice than it does elsewhere as compared to other 19th Century related films. In all, Becky is an overtly sexual object, and is used by women and men as a means of spectatorship and objectification which is portrayed through filmic techniques.
11.12.07
10.12.07
1.10.07
Abismos de Pasion
It is always difficult to consider the value of a film when stood next to its hardback counterpart. Bunuel points out that the purpose was to keep in spirit with Emily Bronte's Wuthering Heights which becomes extremely more difficult the denser the translation. Bunuel does splendidly in portraying a mad love, which Bunuel artistically reveals through the lenses’ perspective. The camera's point of view speaks for the narrative by giving a spectator perspective, which is revealed through a voyeuristic following of actions and situations that almost feel like they should not be watched since the interaction is so intimate. It seemed as though the audience was spying on the other characters, which becomes the case for a few of the characters to help convey their reactions to the situations and also give insight to the internal perspective of the character. Most of the scenes that deal with spying put Alejandro in the victim's seat with Catalina overlooking the interactions between Isabel and Alejandro on the cliff. Eduardo listens at the door when Catalina and Alejandro argue over Isabel and Isabel spies on the return of Catalina and Alejandro. So a central focus is forced on Alejandro through all the character's watchful eyes which help convey his untrustworthy nature. There is always the continuing sense of distrust because Alejandro’s immediate past is clouded with uncertainty and there is the basic assumption that his means to attaining wealth were less than honorable. Only in Catalina does the movie portray a softer side to Alejandro, but after she dies he falls through a momentary lapse of demonic rage in which his face is hidden in the shadows thus hiding the worst part of him from the audience. Bunuel shadows Alejandro is many scenes but it is only during his desperate call from Catalina after her death that he is completely shrouded in darkness.
The relationship between man and nature, or more specifically man and animal also do much to convey the internal workings of each individual character though the only character that does not give any relation or opinion towards animals and possession is Alejandro. Instead, he is referred to as a canaille which can be considered as a dog, riffraff or the proletariat so this representation of him by all the other characters externalizes him from the inward workings of normal society. Discovering this meaning only contributes in the sympathy for Alejandro who does try to justify his behavior by emphasizing his treatment in the past. All the other characters are portrayed as hunters. Catalina kills a buzzard in the opening scene and with that mentions how it is better to kill with one shot. Eduardo, in killing a butterfly, says it is the only humane way to kill the creature while still keeping its beauty intact and Isabel flutters at both for treating the creatures so poorly. Thus Eduardo is focused on preserving the beauty of his object, Catalina of killing it fast and quick, and Isabel by treating it soft and compassionately. All follow suit in their concepts of love. Catalina also gives the funny point of justifying the imprisonment of a bird because she loves it. So again you see her treatment of both men in the same way she treats the animals. Her love for Alejandro can only exist in death and Eduardo's in imprisonment. Again, mad love is brought to mind because there is that sense of hopeless passion and discontent for love on all sides.
Although the movie does follow an extremely dense version of Bronte's plot lines, the movie does do well in keeping the fervent passion alive between Alejandro and Catalina. The ending does Alejandro a great justice for humanizing him by reacquainting him with his perpetual soul mate. The idea of love after death is maintained from print to screen in keeping the spirit of Bronte's vision alive. The only diversion is the new representation of nature in the form of animals though keeping alive the wild and free atmosphere of the open environment in which Catalina and Alejandro escape to profess their love. A simply grotesque scene that keeps alive the animalistic nature of the characters is the scene that shows the death of a pig which is just hideous and barbaric, even with the obvious sound overs of the pig screeching in the film. The spirit of Emily Bronte and the passion that is seen throughout the novel is translated into an animalistic sort of passion that brings out man’s primal instincts towards love and possession which only heightens the sense of darkness within the love story.
The relationship between man and nature, or more specifically man and animal also do much to convey the internal workings of each individual character though the only character that does not give any relation or opinion towards animals and possession is Alejandro. Instead, he is referred to as a canaille which can be considered as a dog, riffraff or the proletariat so this representation of him by all the other characters externalizes him from the inward workings of normal society. Discovering this meaning only contributes in the sympathy for Alejandro who does try to justify his behavior by emphasizing his treatment in the past. All the other characters are portrayed as hunters. Catalina kills a buzzard in the opening scene and with that mentions how it is better to kill with one shot. Eduardo, in killing a butterfly, says it is the only humane way to kill the creature while still keeping its beauty intact and Isabel flutters at both for treating the creatures so poorly. Thus Eduardo is focused on preserving the beauty of his object, Catalina of killing it fast and quick, and Isabel by treating it soft and compassionately. All follow suit in their concepts of love. Catalina also gives the funny point of justifying the imprisonment of a bird because she loves it. So again you see her treatment of both men in the same way she treats the animals. Her love for Alejandro can only exist in death and Eduardo's in imprisonment. Again, mad love is brought to mind because there is that sense of hopeless passion and discontent for love on all sides.
Although the movie does follow an extremely dense version of Bronte's plot lines, the movie does do well in keeping the fervent passion alive between Alejandro and Catalina. The ending does Alejandro a great justice for humanizing him by reacquainting him with his perpetual soul mate. The idea of love after death is maintained from print to screen in keeping the spirit of Bronte's vision alive. The only diversion is the new representation of nature in the form of animals though keeping alive the wild and free atmosphere of the open environment in which Catalina and Alejandro escape to profess their love. A simply grotesque scene that keeps alive the animalistic nature of the characters is the scene that shows the death of a pig which is just hideous and barbaric, even with the obvious sound overs of the pig screeching in the film. The spirit of Emily Bronte and the passion that is seen throughout the novel is translated into an animalistic sort of passion that brings out man’s primal instincts towards love and possession which only heightens the sense of darkness within the love story.
24.9.07
Wuthering Heights
Where to start. On immediate perception I noticed how dramatics were put in play concerning the weather, the lighting, the music, and the landscape. Secondly, I appraised the way in which the film followed the novel from a narrative standpoint that looked beyond Ellen's involvement and focused more on Heathcliff and Catherine in a way that would do Emily Bronte proud. I was however disappointed in the choice to not include little Cathy but nonetheless impressed in how truly the film followed the novel. The film maker obviously took important note of details within the novel to truly humanize and justify Catherine and Heathcliff away from Ellen's judgemental and slightly biased perception. Yet the film did just enough to still be true to Bronte's characterization of the two characters which I considered quite a feat in their efforts to soften the extremely dim tragedy of the two lovers.
Most of the camera shots were taken up close to give a whole perspective of the profile that gave the audience a feel that they were close spectators of the fall. Lighting was manipulated any time the mood changed, from the opening scene which is extremely dark, Ellen takes you right into a happy extremely lighted mood that is all happy which changed upon Heathcliff's arrival. It is interesting to note the changes in the reception of Heathcliff, the gifts were given in one piece, the wife was more than happy to welcome the horrid child. I had to say I appreciated how detail made an effect on the mood, especially the ghost scene which I fearfully watched out of the side of my eyes and I felt it relevant (given the time period) that though the scene was softened a bit it still aroused enough fear to portray to the audience what the character was feeling at that particular time. I thought it interesting that though Ellen is always present within the novel, she be placed to the side and only on screen when her prescence was especially necessary. I thought this helped give a non-judmental perception of the two lovers. The novel was followed fairly literally in the play which little changes to both reflect the mood of the time and censor any over the top moments from the novel.
Well, not to certainly say censor but especially soften the mood. Catherine was not so nearly as tempermental as she was given to be in the novel, nor Mr. Heathcliff as horrendous. Ellen actually attributed an affinity for her mistress and seemed extremely supportive of the match. Even the dance scene attributed to reflecting the time period in which the movie was made, whether intentional or no. It did well in portraying a certain civility that was otherwise extremely lacking in the novel.
The continuous music I did find frustrating because I understood the relevance of the music in portraying the mood but on the same point the music never stopped throughout the first 15 minutes and I felt that more detracted from the story instead of amplifying it.
To accertain this point here are the first 9 minutes of the movie.
All in all I was extremely proud of this rendition of Wuthering Heights because it did amazing justice to the novel and brought of the characters in a true manner that was conveyed through the author's characterization. This movie insights pangs and awes and does justice to their tragic love.
Most of the camera shots were taken up close to give a whole perspective of the profile that gave the audience a feel that they were close spectators of the fall. Lighting was manipulated any time the mood changed, from the opening scene which is extremely dark, Ellen takes you right into a happy extremely lighted mood that is all happy which changed upon Heathcliff's arrival. It is interesting to note the changes in the reception of Heathcliff, the gifts were given in one piece, the wife was more than happy to welcome the horrid child. I had to say I appreciated how detail made an effect on the mood, especially the ghost scene which I fearfully watched out of the side of my eyes and I felt it relevant (given the time period) that though the scene was softened a bit it still aroused enough fear to portray to the audience what the character was feeling at that particular time. I thought it interesting that though Ellen is always present within the novel, she be placed to the side and only on screen when her prescence was especially necessary. I thought this helped give a non-judmental perception of the two lovers. The novel was followed fairly literally in the play which little changes to both reflect the mood of the time and censor any over the top moments from the novel.
Well, not to certainly say censor but especially soften the mood. Catherine was not so nearly as tempermental as she was given to be in the novel, nor Mr. Heathcliff as horrendous. Ellen actually attributed an affinity for her mistress and seemed extremely supportive of the match. Even the dance scene attributed to reflecting the time period in which the movie was made, whether intentional or no. It did well in portraying a certain civility that was otherwise extremely lacking in the novel.
The continuous music I did find frustrating because I understood the relevance of the music in portraying the mood but on the same point the music never stopped throughout the first 15 minutes and I felt that more detracted from the story instead of amplifying it.
To accertain this point here are the first 9 minutes of the movie.
All in all I was extremely proud of this rendition of Wuthering Heights because it did amazing justice to the novel and brought of the characters in a true manner that was conveyed through the author's characterization. This movie insights pangs and awes and does justice to their tragic love.
Bride and Prejudice
If it were not for the cheesy dialogue and the many references to american stereotypee, Bride and Prejudice could pass for a decent romance.
Forgive me, I don't mean to be harsh but I found the discourse unlikeable and extremely ignorant (or satirical) of the american language, and the scenes a little cliche. I found the dance scenes a little enjoyable and I did appreciate the humor but overall I felt that the film was a deadpan for what could pass as a weak satire on american imperialism.
What I found most painful were the several references to stereotypical american life. Cokes were referenced way too often and I felt it odd that all the beverages in the movie were american and were literally called out by name. Ashanti was a nice addition to the overall theme of american versus indian but let's focus more on why the movie could have been insulting and more on the actual thematics of the movie.
That the lead was fair and blue eyed was curious. There were many references to the traditional modern woman which I found an interesting twist on the film. The film offered an opposition of American and Indian which gave insight to the actual practices of marriage in India. Pride and Prejudice would especially be interesting to transform for Indian audiences because of the ability to sympathize and relate to marriage practices.
To focus on the Bollywood aspect of the film, I felt a few of the scenes could do little better than soft core porn. The colors were ecstatic and overwhelming, the choice in words during the musical numbers grating, and the acting above all else was horrendous. Part of Mr. Darcy's job in the film is to portray himself in a consistent manner as to give light to his softer side. Mr. Darcy is not just pretentious in the film, he is also greedy, monetarily focused, and extremely selfish in the "I'm going to please myself and damn any other response." I did find the film maker's choice to give Mr. Darcy a mother, or any semblance of a family when in the film there were none. I felt this choice did little but overcast the cliched stereotype of a rich mother trying to suit her son with the perfect (wealty) daughter. I would have enjoyed Georgiana more had the actor contained a little more of the character's charm and of all the characters I would argue that only Mr. Wickham was true to character, even through a modernized version.
Sexual undertones are apparent throughout with the sexual movements of the women in all of their dances, and even the puns are so ridiculous as to leave the audience cringing in their seat in a "I can't believe they said that" moment. There is even a small reference to Lolita but not to the story, only the name. The film was in many parts close to being effective but seemed unable to make the whole connection.
Again, the soundtrack choices outside the musical numbers were curious because they were chosen to offer an opposition between American and Indian. The color did enough to over emphacize the flamboyant nature of the women which was waaaay off point when considering the subtle Austen. Also, the references to a global dating service and any sort of technical references does little but detract from the romance which was already made cheesy with the horrible one liners. All in all the romance was died and buried within Bride and Prejudice. All that survived were semi political implications and oppositions of traditional versus modern. Had the movie not portrayed the stereotypical america I might have been less insulted but I am still confused on the point of whether or not the movie was a satire on american life or was indeed and romantic appeal to the marriage plot.
To get other insights here is the review of this film on the roger ebert website
http://rogerebert.suntimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20050210/REVIEWS/502100302/1023
Note how the main focus is on the main actress and her beauty.
And for another enjoyable piece that should gain a laugh or two here is the infamous dance in the opening scene.
The women do appear to have a curious power over the men, no?
Forgive me, I don't mean to be harsh but I found the discourse unlikeable and extremely ignorant (or satirical) of the american language, and the scenes a little cliche. I found the dance scenes a little enjoyable and I did appreciate the humor but overall I felt that the film was a deadpan for what could pass as a weak satire on american imperialism.
What I found most painful were the several references to stereotypical american life. Cokes were referenced way too often and I felt it odd that all the beverages in the movie were american and were literally called out by name. Ashanti was a nice addition to the overall theme of american versus indian but let's focus more on why the movie could have been insulting and more on the actual thematics of the movie.
That the lead was fair and blue eyed was curious. There were many references to the traditional modern woman which I found an interesting twist on the film. The film offered an opposition of American and Indian which gave insight to the actual practices of marriage in India. Pride and Prejudice would especially be interesting to transform for Indian audiences because of the ability to sympathize and relate to marriage practices.
To focus on the Bollywood aspect of the film, I felt a few of the scenes could do little better than soft core porn. The colors were ecstatic and overwhelming, the choice in words during the musical numbers grating, and the acting above all else was horrendous. Part of Mr. Darcy's job in the film is to portray himself in a consistent manner as to give light to his softer side. Mr. Darcy is not just pretentious in the film, he is also greedy, monetarily focused, and extremely selfish in the "I'm going to please myself and damn any other response." I did find the film maker's choice to give Mr. Darcy a mother, or any semblance of a family when in the film there were none. I felt this choice did little but overcast the cliched stereotype of a rich mother trying to suit her son with the perfect (wealty) daughter. I would have enjoyed Georgiana more had the actor contained a little more of the character's charm and of all the characters I would argue that only Mr. Wickham was true to character, even through a modernized version.
Sexual undertones are apparent throughout with the sexual movements of the women in all of their dances, and even the puns are so ridiculous as to leave the audience cringing in their seat in a "I can't believe they said that" moment. There is even a small reference to Lolita but not to the story, only the name. The film was in many parts close to being effective but seemed unable to make the whole connection.
Again, the soundtrack choices outside the musical numbers were curious because they were chosen to offer an opposition between American and Indian. The color did enough to over emphacize the flamboyant nature of the women which was waaaay off point when considering the subtle Austen. Also, the references to a global dating service and any sort of technical references does little but detract from the romance which was already made cheesy with the horrible one liners. All in all the romance was died and buried within Bride and Prejudice. All that survived were semi political implications and oppositions of traditional versus modern. Had the movie not portrayed the stereotypical america I might have been less insulted but I am still confused on the point of whether or not the movie was a satire on american life or was indeed and romantic appeal to the marriage plot.
To get other insights here is the review of this film on the roger ebert website
http://rogerebert.suntimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20050210/REVIEWS/502100302/1023
Note how the main focus is on the main actress and her beauty.
And for another enjoyable piece that should gain a laugh or two here is the infamous dance in the opening scene.
The women do appear to have a curious power over the men, no?
13.9.07
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
